Ireland's Greatest Cricketers 10: Stuart Pollock
John Stuart Pollock
Stuart Pollock, son of former Irish captain and stylish batting all rounder William, was, for about ten years after the Second World War, the best batsman in Ireland. Statisticians might call this into question by quoting some of his figures, but few, if any, who had the good fortune to see him bat, would disagree.
Very quick on his feet, he excelled with the hook, but had a wide array of strokes, equally at home off either foot. He was a destroyer of bowling at club level, and, on his day, could repeat this at a higher sphere. He did not always satisfy his critics. Thus Pat Hone, a self professed admirer of his batting wrote, while Pollock was still playing that, "He too often presents his wicket to the bowler for no good reason."
He was said to lack concentration. He would, it was claimed have been a better player if he had curbed his natural aggression somewhat. Hone felt that he came down the wicket too much, even in defence. He was also said to have too much bottom hand in his shots. This writer, who counts himself privileged to have seen Stuart in his pomp in full cry, would not have had him any other way and nor, he suspects, would the great mass of those who have similar recollections. And as for too much bottom hand? Well, they used to say the same about Peter May!
Stuart was also a superb fieldsman, in the cover point or mid wicket areas, and sometimes turned his arm over to deliver off spin of slightly less than Laker like quality. An outstanding all round sportsmen at Campbell College, Stuart gained a regular place in the NICC side in 1938, and apart from war service, was a first choice selection until back trouble and pressure of work brought about his retirement in 1962.
He headed the averages 8 times, captaining the team from 1948 to 1950 and, again, in 1960 when he led them to the League Cup double, taking a leading role in the Cup Final with 72* in North's first innings of 150. Allied to "Sonny" Hool's spin it gave the Ormeau side an 8 wicket victory. There were several rain breaks and the wicket always took spin. This innings showed not only Stuart's qualities but, as was also evident in his international career, his flair for the big occasion.
He had also hit a brilliant 111* v Sion Mills in the Cup in the previous season, having already made 84 against the villagers on an earlier occasion. He was also in the Cup winning teams of 1938, 1951 and 1956. On the third occasion, his second innings 47 was a crucial contribution to his side's success. They had trailed Lurgan by 30 in the first innings, and as the final margin was an 18 run victory, Stuart cleanly made the vital contribution with the bat, though he would have been the first to acknowledge the all round performance of Stan Hewitt and the bowling of Hool.
For Ireland he played 41 times scoring 1506 runs at 21.51. His critics have not been slow to point to this as underachievement and to highlight his eleven ducks. They believe that his one century, 129 v Scotland in College Park in 1951, and 9 fifties should have been improved upon. It is, however, true that he rose to a challenge, some of his best innings being against the strongest opposition. Thus his best knock for the national side is said to have been his 75 minute 89 v Yorkshire at Ormeau in 1949.
On a turning wicket, Ireland were bowled out for 57 in the first innings with great left armer Johnny Wardle, and classy off spinner Ellis Robinson, doing the damage. Yorkshire also struggled in the conditions and a lunchtime declaration by England captain Norman Yardley left Ireland 410 to make or 240 minutes to bat out. With both options unlikely Stuart, abetted by Bobby Barnes and George Wilson went for the bowling. Savaging Wardle and Robinson, he showed the Belfast cricket crowd, just how thin Wardle's veneer of good nature was. He got Stuart in the end, stumped by wicket keeper Don Brennan, who, two years later briefly replaced the great Godfrey Evans in the Test side. However the spinners figures are worth recording; Robinson 24.1-2-106-4 and Wardle 24-5-105-5 .
Stuart's big occasion flair, first shown as a 19 year old with 35 and 25 on debut v Scotland in 1939, having been 12th man against the Australians at Ormeau the previous year, was also seen to good account against South Africa at Ormeau in 1951 and India in College Park in 1952. Against the South Africans he belied his critics with a patient innings against the off spin of Athol Rowan (3/49) and the slow left arm of "Tufty" Mann (4/48) so that Ireland gained a slender lead.
Unfortunately they then collapsed against the spinners, with only Tom McCloy reaching double figures. In 1952 India forced Ireland to follow on in College Park, Stuart being caught behind for a duck off pace bowling Oxford blue, RV Divecha. In the follow on Stuart and Eddie Ingram(54) both made half centuries, Stuart being caught and bowled by all rounder GS Ramchand, a future Indian captain. Other noteworthy innings were his 76 v MCC at Lord's in 1949, the fine summer clearly suiting him, and 82 at the same venue in 1953. "Pollock, an entertaining batsman, gave an aggressive display of driving," commented Wisden.
His final match for Ireland was on a gloomy weekend at Rathmines in September 1957 against a Free Forester side of almost insulting weakness. The FF bowling was put to the sword with Stuart signing off with a majestic 64. His captaincy of Ireland was not a great success, winning only one of the ten matches in which he was in charge between 1951 and 1955, though this is, in part, due to strength of opposition, with four matches against Test sides being included.
His prowess was recognised across the water and he was often in demand for MCC and FF teams. Three of these matches were first class. In 1954 v Cambridge at Lord's he hit a classy second innings 46, which, though the hosts top score was not enough to stave off an innings defeat. The MCC side had included two England captains but an astonishing hundred by the University number 8, JF Pretlove, was too much for them. Stuart was more successful against Oxford in 1956. He made 82 catching the eye of Wisden as did the Leicestershire opener Maurice Hallam (136). "Hallam... and Pollock, the Irish batsman excelled for MCC." The MCC side included two former West Indian Test men Gerry Gomez and Dr CB Bertie" Clarke. He also appeared for the Free Foresters against at Cambridge in 1958, but without much success.
After his retirement, he remained a prominent figure being President of the Irish Cricket Union in 1980, in which role he was described by Derek Scott in the 1981 ICU Yearbook, as, "much travelled, popular and successful." His Presidency of the Leprechauns also attracted much praise and favourable comment. He also became captain of The Royal County Down Golf Club. Though cricket was always the main sport of this man, who once owned a pair of dogs called Grace and Hutton, it was not his only sport. As befitted his quick footed batting he was an outstanding squash player and also reached trialist status as a centre three quarter and a hockey forward.
Fittingly, his name features beside that of his father in Siggins and Fitzgerald "Ireland's 100 Cricket Greats"
Edward Liddle, March 2008
© CricketEurope, Cricket Ireland
Ireland v England 2011RSA Challenge, Ireland v England
Thursday 25 August, Clontarf
Tickets may be purchased online, by telephone, or via the Cricket Ireland office.
» Ticket ordering info
MembershipCricket Ireland offers a range of membership packages for 2011 - whatever your need, there's a package for you!
» Membership details
MerchandiseThe new range of Irish replica and supporters gear is available through Lion Sports.
» Order now online!